The Best — As I See It!
SEE RELATED:Part IV: Running Backs
by
Robert Janis
What is really fun about being a fan of a long established pro sports franchise is that you have an ever filling reservoir of players from which to choose for your list of best in a particular position. And, being a fan of the team whether it is for 50 years or five years means that you can fall back on your own personal opinion when making your own list of the best.
What follows is my list of the best Washington Redskins by squad.
Part I will cover the offensive line.
Part II will identify the best receivers.
Part III will list the best quarterbacks.
Part IV will describe the best running backs.
Part V goes into the best defensive linemen.
Part VI covers the linebackers.
Part VII is for the defensive linemen.
Part VIII will discuss the best linebackers.
Part IX will i.d. the best defensive backs.
Again, this is my opinion. I encourage you to post your list of the best in a particular position as a comment to my article that covers that position. For example, no doubt you have your own opinions on who were the best Washington Redskins running backs. Post your picks as a comment to my article.
My Nominating Process
In making the selection of the best running backs I relied on my memory — I saw all of these guys play — statistics — I guess you can’t ignore the stats — and the list of the 70 Greatest Redskins.
Running backs on that list are:
Don Bossler (1957-1964)
Larry Brown (1969-1976)
John Riggins (1976-1979, 1981-1985)
Terry Allen (1995-1998)
Ernest Byner (1989-1993)
Dickie James 1955-1963)
Here’s where my personal experience comes in. I watched Don Bossler play. And, no offense to Don Bossler, he doesn’t match up with the other players on the list. So, using my power — this is my list after all — Bossler is cut.
Next, the 70 Greatest Redskins List was compiled in 2002 when the franchise celebrated its 70th Anniversary. So it did not include at least two Redskins backs who should be considered among the best — Steven Davis and Clinton Portis.
Now, let’s look at the stats. I know that many of you are not keened on stats. But in my opinion, they should have a say in the process.
Larry Brown
Total Yards Rushing: 5,875
TDs Rushing: 35
Receptions: 238
Total Yards Receiving: 2,485
TDs Receiving 20
4 Pro Bowls (1969, 1970, 1971, 1972)
3 All Pro Selections (1970, 1971, 1972)
MVP 1972
NFL Offensive Player of the Year 1972
UPI, NFL Player of the Year 1972
Dickie James (8 seasons with Redskins)
Total Yards Rushing: 1,741
TDs Rushing: 16
Total Receptions: 92
Total Yards Receiving: 1,568
TDs Receiving: 14
All Purpose Yards: 9,227
1 Pro Bowl (1961)
Terry Allen
Total Yards Rushing: 4,086
39 TDs
Total Receptions: 100
Total Yards Receiving: 726
Steven Davis (7 seasons with Redskins)
Total Yards Rushing: 5790
TDs: 53
Total Receptions: 146
Total Yards Receiving: 1168
Ernest Byner (5 seasons with Redskins)
Total Yards Rushing: 3950
Total TDs: 18
Total Receptions: 185
Total Yards Receiving: 1577
2 Pro Bowls (1990, 1991)
Super Bowl
Clinton Portis (4 seasons with Redskins)
Total Yards Rushing: 4,616
Total TDs: 36
Total Receptions: 134
Total Yards Receiving: 1010
John Riggins
Total Yards Rushing: 7,472
Total TDs: 85
Total Receptions: 121
Total Yards Receiving: 928
2 Times All Pro (1975, 1983)
NFL 80s All Decade Team
MVP Super Bowl XVII
NFL Comeback Player of the Year: 1978
Pro Football Hall of Fame
Final Selection
So taking into account the stats, the honors/awards and having seen each one play, here is my selection of the best Redskins running backs in order:
John Riggins — It really couldn’t be anyone else. Watching that touchdown run against the Dolphins to win a Super Bowl is enough to make him #1.
Larry Brown — The stats prove it, the awards prove it and his running style proves it. He could have played for a few more years if George Allen didn’t over use him.
Steven Davis — No doubt a surprise to you. Definitely a surprise to me. But his stats make him worthy — yards and touchdowns — and he went on to prove himself with another team — Carolina Panthers. I don’t think Turner and Marty knew how to use him. And Spurrier let him go for a guy name, what? Trunge Candidate??
Clinton Portis — His numbers are good and he’s still playing. And he’s a good team leader. I think he keeps things lose in the locker room. I just wish that he could add a Super Bowl to his resume.
Ernest Byner — I debated placing Byner third or fourth. After all he did help us reach and win a Super Bowl.
And let’s give a nod to some of the “fill in” backs — the guys who played between Brown and Riggins — say, like Mike Thomas. We also had a couple of one year wonders like Reggie Brooks that I just can’t shake from my memory.
Mike Thomas (1975 - 1978)
Total Yards Rushing: 3359
Reggie Brooks (1993 - 1995)
1993 Total Yards Rushing: 1069
1994 Total Yards Rushing: 297
1995 Total Yards Rushing: -2
Runner Up for rookie of the year in 1993
All Rookie Team 1993
First Redskins Rookie to gain over 1,000 yards
But a special place in my memory goes to Dickie James. I used to say that if he was just one step faster … And not only was he a running back, he was also a receiver, defensive back, and punt and kick off returner. He was truly a work horse for those Redskins teams that played in the late ‘50s into the early ‘60s. And he was responsible for us getting Sam Huff. Dickie James was part of the deal that got Sam Huff from the New York Giants to the Redskins.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.