That was a key takeaway from the annual Asan Plenum, a major security conference held in Seoul this week. Scholars of modern warfare noted that today’s current-generation, cross-domain conflicts are — to borrow a phrase from Hollywood — “everything, everywhere, all at once.”
Adversarial states and non-state actors such as Islamic State and al Qaeda are deploying asymmetric assets that operate at low risk and low cost across new real and virtual battlefields, assets to which the U.S. and its allies have so far been unable to respond effectively.
Washington Times Asia Editor Andrew Salmon reports from the conference that there are few or no rules or laws to govern emerging domains like cyberspace, outer space and “gray zone” tactics. The failure of deterrence in modern conflicts also poses a major dilemma for the U.S. and its allies.
“How do you compete in a constant competition/conflict continuum short of all-out war, while ensuring deterrence is assured?” asked Diana Myers, an ex-fellow with the Rand Corp. “The things that keep me up are non-kinetic: the ability for malicious nations and non-aligned actors to challenge how we receive and process information.” There are “Orwellian” solutions to this problem, policing speech and political content, “but we are not that,” she said. “It puts us in a complicated situation.”